“Why do I keep choosing emotionally unavailable people?”
As a Psychotherapist, it’s one of the questions I’m asked most often and if I truly had the definitive answer, it would probably be worth a million pounds.
The assumption behind the question is that emotional unavailability belongs to the other person. That they are the problem to be solved, the pattern to be broken, the trait to be avoided next time.
But what if the question is incomplete?
What if, in choosing someone emotionally unavailable, we are also revealing something about our own emotional availability?
Emotionally unavailable people are often deeply attractive. They keep us guessing. That pursuer-retreater dance can be incredibly seductive.
Not because they are unavailable, but because they awaken something within us that feels strangely familiar. They can appear charismatic, independent, exciting, unpredictable, and emotionally intense in fleeting moments. We experience the thrill of connection, followed by the ache of distance.
Sometimes we mistake inconsistency for chemistry.
Sometimes we mistake longing for love.
Sometimes we spend so much energy trying to be chosen that we never stop to ask whether the relationship itself is meeting our emotional needs.
Perhaps the pursuit feels safer than the possibility of being fully loved.
Now let me introduce a slight curveball…
What if you are emotionally unavailable too?
Not in the obvious way.
Emotional unavailability can be surprisingly subtle.
It can look like choosing people who cannot fully commit.
It can look like always having one foot outside the relationship.
It can look like needing certainty before allowing yourself to be truly vulnerable.
It can look like intellectualising your emotions instead of simply feeling them.
It can look like protecting yourself so well that no one ever truly gets close enough to hurt you.
We should also consider that not everyone who longs for love is emotionally available to receive it.
Emotional unavailability is rarely about not caring.
More often, it is protection.
It may be the remnants of childhood experiences where closeness felt unsafe. It may follow betrayal, grief, loss, divorce, or repeated relational disappointment. Sometimes it reflects a fear of dependence. Sometimes it is the quiet belief that if you never give someone all of yourself, they can never be in a position to completely break you.
We all develop ways of protecting our hearts.
Some of those protections eventually become prisons.
Maybe emotionally unavailable people are not difficult to love.
Maybe they are frightened of what love asks of them.
The greatest challenge, then, is not simply finding someone who is emotionally available.
It is becoming emotionally available ourselves.
To risk being known.
To tolerate uncertainty.
To remain present when intimacy feels uncomfortable.
To accept that love cannot exist without vulnerability.
Perhaps the question was never, “Why do I keep choosing emotionally unavailable people?”
Perhaps the real question is, “Can I become curious enough to understand that my patterns are not about assigning blame, but about discovering where they began and finding the courage to choose differently?”
Warmly
Jules
